"“Bourgeoisie” should be read as the Christian middle class.”
… and the peasantry and the proletariat in whose name this real judaic holocaust was unleashed upon Russia.
I would also be interesting to find out how many among the “bourgeoisie” — i.e., people who owned businesses, were well-healed— who were executed were Jews. The Jews surely must have been overrepresented in the “bourgeoisie,” so one would expect them to also be overrepresented among the victims of Red Terror.
Leon Davidovich Bronstein, a.k.a. Trotsky was, per wikipedia, "Born into a wealthy Jewish family in Ukraine, then part of the Russian Empire.”
I listened to your reading (hard to bear, as you predicted at the beginning) yet somehow I missed the part where you say that he was among the first to be summarily executed. How come?
In 2013, speaking at the Moscow Jewish Museum and Center for Tolerance, President Putin said:
"The decision to nationalize the [Scheersohn] library was made by the first Soviet government, and Jews were approximately 80–85% members”.
"Владимир Путин решил судьбу библиотеки Шнеерсона". Российская газета (in Russian). 13 June 2013.
Oh, no, that might fuel ignorant, anti-semites’ conspiracy theories...
As "Polish" philosopher and leader of the Jewish community in Poland Stanislaw Krajewsky stated:
"Overrepresentation of a group in a political movement does not prove either that the movement was 'dominated' by that group or that it primarily serves that group's interests.”
Hold that thought any time the Jewish ownership of the financial system, the selectively “elected” government, the education system, media and entertainment in the US is mentioned.
Also, when you remember the Red Terror don't think of the Blue Terror unleashed upon Palestine by the descendants of the Red Terror perpetrators. No, that does not matter because the slogans are different...
Trotsky wasn't executed in the purge of the Old Bolsheviks in the 30s, when, for example, Latsis was executed, though. He lasted until1940. What I find most appalling is that Trotsky is included in the Museum of the Jewish People in Tel Aviv as part of the permanent exhibit of "Heroes of the Jewish People." Cue Leonard Cohen's Heneni. Judaism is a disease.
I saw a speech Putin was delivering to a large Russian audience of top officials and such and, appearing to go off script, said that the people in control of the West weren't Westerners and that they were so power-mad and ruthless that they would "sacrifice Israel itself to gain their goals."
Now that is a remarkable thing to say. Then he said, believe it or not, but it's true.
Couple that with that one-on-one meeting he had with Trump in Trump's first term--the meeting that had the Jews in Congress threatening to arrest the translator and force him to divulge what was said, and I find cause for hope. We have so few.
I'm going to keep putting up these readings. I wish there were a way to do it without flooding people's inboxes. But I want the book up there in audio format.
Every time I read or hear Melgunov's book, I'm struck by how the outrages that were being committed against such defenceless people were not some secret in the outside world. Just like with Gaza today, people in other countries knew what was going on, people wrung their hands, people shook their heads in disbelief and dismay... and yet the Powers in the world had their way.
And then, after scarcely a generation had passed, the Soviet's crimes were somehow "forgotten" and the West allied with the Soviets against a Germany that was trying to stand up to Communism and Jewish Power.
A few more generations go by, and everything seems to have been forgotten - even by the descendants of the original victims. If they knew their own history, how could modern-day Ukrainians have ever elected a Jew like Zelensky, backed by a Jewish billionaire oligarch (Ihor Kolomoyskyi)?
But then all I have to do is look at the results of yesterday's Canadian federal election. After the Liberal Party presided over the entire covid scamdemic (which I believe is another genocide, albeit in slow motion), Canadians have just returned the same party to government - and by a majority, no less. Yes, we got rid of Turdeau, but now the Liberals are under the leadership of an international bankster with long-standing ties to the WEF and Epstein-Maxwell.
I'm left wondering what it is like to live in the average "normie's" headspace... but maybe I don't want to know. It might drive me mad.
Hey thanks Anna. Nothing like the quality material you and Steve produce, of course, but I happened to check out the traffic the old podcasts were getting and was surprised at the amount, so I decided to just keep going with it since people are interested.
As for what it's like living inside the average normie's headspace, I imagine it's echo-y.
The more casual approach you used is kind of like listening to something that is done live, and the small hiccups actually make the delivery very human.
Refreshing, to say the least, in a world where they're constantly trying to sell us on AI. For example, AI would have never thought to throw in the mosquito attack. Something we can all relate to!
I also thought it was very effective that you could break off from the reading at the drop of a hat to explain terms or details that might have been lost on the average listener.
Not everyone could do this the way you do. It's heavy material, but you have a certain charm. I'm looking forward to more.
Correction: the Liberals only won a minority, not a majority, government... and they have to do re-counts in several ridings because the results were too close. Mea culpa.
I am shocked at how easy it is to turn over the serious historical topic of the Russian Revolution to the Jewish nationality (in Soviet or Bolshevik Russia, if you prefer, Jewishness is a nationality) responsible for all the bloody tragedy, which happened in Soviet Russia after the Revolution and had stopped only after Stalin death in 1953. I am a Russian. My father, as a young writer, was sent to the Gulag for his first novel, "Bread," because his novel was about bloody Stalin's Collectivization. Of course, Jews participated in the revolution; all nationalities of the Russian Empire participated in the Revolution. Why do you make the Jews responsible? Only because of S. Melgunov's book? What did he know, escaping Bolshevism? On my bookshelves, at least, twelve books about Lenin, Stalin, and Trotsky by different authors of Russian, English, and American historians investigating this topic. Read the objective literature.
"“Bourgeoisie” should be read as the Christian middle class.”
… and the peasantry and the proletariat in whose name this real judaic holocaust was unleashed upon Russia.
I would also be interesting to find out how many among the “bourgeoisie” — i.e., people who owned businesses, were well-healed— who were executed were Jews. The Jews surely must have been overrepresented in the “bourgeoisie,” so one would expect them to also be overrepresented among the victims of Red Terror.
Leon Davidovich Bronstein, a.k.a. Trotsky was, per wikipedia, "Born into a wealthy Jewish family in Ukraine, then part of the Russian Empire.”
I listened to your reading (hard to bear, as you predicted at the beginning) yet somehow I missed the part where you say that he was among the first to be summarily executed. How come?
In 2013, speaking at the Moscow Jewish Museum and Center for Tolerance, President Putin said:
"The decision to nationalize the [Scheersohn] library was made by the first Soviet government, and Jews were approximately 80–85% members”.
"Владимир Путин решил судьбу библиотеки Шнеерсона". Российская газета (in Russian). 13 June 2013.
Oh, no, that might fuel ignorant, anti-semites’ conspiracy theories...
As "Polish" philosopher and leader of the Jewish community in Poland Stanislaw Krajewsky stated:
"Overrepresentation of a group in a political movement does not prove either that the movement was 'dominated' by that group or that it primarily serves that group's interests.”
Hold that thought any time the Jewish ownership of the financial system, the selectively “elected” government, the education system, media and entertainment in the US is mentioned.
Also, when you remember the Red Terror don't think of the Blue Terror unleashed upon Palestine by the descendants of the Red Terror perpetrators. No, that does not matter because the slogans are different...
THANK you, Craig!
Trotsky wasn't executed in the purge of the Old Bolsheviks in the 30s, when, for example, Latsis was executed, though. He lasted until1940. What I find most appalling is that Trotsky is included in the Museum of the Jewish People in Tel Aviv as part of the permanent exhibit of "Heroes of the Jewish People." Cue Leonard Cohen's Heneni. Judaism is a disease.
I saw a speech Putin was delivering to a large Russian audience of top officials and such and, appearing to go off script, said that the people in control of the West weren't Westerners and that they were so power-mad and ruthless that they would "sacrifice Israel itself to gain their goals."
Now that is a remarkable thing to say. Then he said, believe it or not, but it's true.
Couple that with that one-on-one meeting he had with Trump in Trump's first term--the meeting that had the Jews in Congress threatening to arrest the translator and force him to divulge what was said, and I find cause for hope. We have so few.
I'm going to keep putting up these readings. I wish there were a way to do it without flooding people's inboxes. But I want the book up there in audio format.
Great reading, Craig, of very difficult material.
Every time I read or hear Melgunov's book, I'm struck by how the outrages that were being committed against such defenceless people were not some secret in the outside world. Just like with Gaza today, people in other countries knew what was going on, people wrung their hands, people shook their heads in disbelief and dismay... and yet the Powers in the world had their way.
And then, after scarcely a generation had passed, the Soviet's crimes were somehow "forgotten" and the West allied with the Soviets against a Germany that was trying to stand up to Communism and Jewish Power.
A few more generations go by, and everything seems to have been forgotten - even by the descendants of the original victims. If they knew their own history, how could modern-day Ukrainians have ever elected a Jew like Zelensky, backed by a Jewish billionaire oligarch (Ihor Kolomoyskyi)?
But then all I have to do is look at the results of yesterday's Canadian federal election. After the Liberal Party presided over the entire covid scamdemic (which I believe is another genocide, albeit in slow motion), Canadians have just returned the same party to government - and by a majority, no less. Yes, we got rid of Turdeau, but now the Liberals are under the leadership of an international bankster with long-standing ties to the WEF and Epstein-Maxwell.
I'm left wondering what it is like to live in the average "normie's" headspace... but maybe I don't want to know. It might drive me mad.
Thanks to everyone here for staying sane.
Hey thanks Anna. Nothing like the quality material you and Steve produce, of course, but I happened to check out the traffic the old podcasts were getting and was surprised at the amount, so I decided to just keep going with it since people are interested.
As for what it's like living inside the average normie's headspace, I imagine it's echo-y.
I really like the way you made this work.
The more casual approach you used is kind of like listening to something that is done live, and the small hiccups actually make the delivery very human.
Refreshing, to say the least, in a world where they're constantly trying to sell us on AI. For example, AI would have never thought to throw in the mosquito attack. Something we can all relate to!
I also thought it was very effective that you could break off from the reading at the drop of a hat to explain terms or details that might have been lost on the average listener.
Not everyone could do this the way you do. It's heavy material, but you have a certain charm. I'm looking forward to more.
Thank you for saying this.
Correction: the Liberals only won a minority, not a majority, government... and they have to do re-counts in several ridings because the results were too close. Mea culpa.
A recent post I saw on MoA:
I am not denying the Holocaust itself but the size of it.
According to Encyclopedia Britannica there were 15.1 MM Jews in 1938; in 1948 there were 15.2 MM Jews living in Europe.
How in the hell then do you fit in 6 MM dying?
You cannot.
I think the size of the Holocaust is between 600k and 1 MM not 6 MM.
Posted by: canuck | Apr 30 2025 12:23 utc | 215
👍 Thank you.
I am shocked at how easy it is to turn over the serious historical topic of the Russian Revolution to the Jewish nationality (in Soviet or Bolshevik Russia, if you prefer, Jewishness is a nationality) responsible for all the bloody tragedy, which happened in Soviet Russia after the Revolution and had stopped only after Stalin death in 1953. I am a Russian. My father, as a young writer, was sent to the Gulag for his first novel, "Bread," because his novel was about bloody Stalin's Collectivization. Of course, Jews participated in the revolution; all nationalities of the Russian Empire participated in the Revolution. Why do you make the Jews responsible? Only because of S. Melgunov's book? What did he know, escaping Bolshevism? On my bookshelves, at least, twelve books about Lenin, Stalin, and Trotsky by different authors of Russian, English, and American historians investigating this topic. Read the objective literature.